Reading Time: 4 minutes
She had an impressive CV. Ten years’ experience, glowing references, confident answers to every interview question. You offered her the position immediately.
Three weeks later, you’re watching her struggle with a basic balayage while your loyal client sits uncomfortably, checking her phone. The technique is outdated, the placement is wrong, and you’re realising this “experienced professional” hasn’t kept pace with modern standards.
The CV lied. The interview didn’t reveal the truth. And now you’re facing an expensive problem.
Here’s what most salon owners learn too late: interviews reveal who can talk about the work. Practical tests reveal who can actually do it. The beauty industry is built on skill, not conversation, yet most hiring decisions are made entirely through talking.
By the end of this article, you’ll know exactly how to structure practical assessments that reveal real ability, which tests work for different roles, how to score results fairly, and the legal considerations that protect both you and your candidates. You’ll stop hiring people who sound perfect and start hiring people who perform perfectly.
Why Your Industry Demands Practical Testing
Unlike office roles where you’re hiring for organisational or communication skills, you’re hiring hands. The work is physical, technical, and immediately visible to clients who will judge your entire business based on what happens in that chair.
A receptionist who interviews poorly might still be brilliant at managing your booking system. But a stylist who can’t execute a proper consultation or a therapist who uses incorrect massage pressure? There’s no hiding that from clients.
Traditional interviews assess personality, culture fit, and communication (all important factors), but they don’t tell you if someone can blend a seamless colour transition, perform a relaxing hot stone massage, or execute precise nail art. Salon Recruiter helps South African beauty businesses find qualified professionals, but the final skills assessment always belongs to you.
Practical tests aren’t about making candidates nervous or showing off your expertise. They’re about protecting your business, your clients, and your reputation from expensive hiring mistakes.
What Practical Tests Actually Reveal
A well-designed practical assessment shows you five critical things that interviews miss:
Current Technical Ability
CVs list qualifications from years ago. Practical tests show what candidates can do today, right now, with their actual hands. You’ll see immediately whether their skills match their claims or whether you’re looking at someone who trained five years ago and hasn’t touched the craft since.
Work Pace and Efficiency
Speed matters in a commercial salon. Practical tests reveal whether candidates work at a pace that matches your business model or whether they’ll struggle to meet appointment schedules. You’ll see if they’re methodical and efficient or slow and disorganised.
Client Interaction During Service
Watch how they communicate whilst working. Do they explain what they’re doing? Do they check in about comfort and preferences? Do they build rapport naturally or focus solely on the technical task? Client retention depends on both skill and connection.
Attention to Detail and Finishing
Anyone can execute the main technique. Professionals understand that finishing separates good work from great work. Practical tests show whether candidates naturally attend to details like clean lines, even application, proper product removal, and presentation.
How They Handle Pressure and Observation
Being watched whilst working is uncomfortable. Candidates who maintain composure, ask clarifying questions when needed, and perform confidently under observation will handle your salon environment better than those who become flustered or defensive.
Designing Tests for Different Roles
Your practical assessment should match both the role level and the specific position you’re filling.
For Junior Stylists or Therapists
Focus on foundational skills rather than advanced techniques. Ask them to demonstrate a basic blow-dry, a simple massage sequence, or a standard manicure. You’re assessing whether they learned proper technique in training and can execute basics competently.
Keep tests short, 45 minutes maximum. Provide clear instructions about what you want to see. Junior candidates should demonstrate solid fundamentals, willingness to receive feedback, and appropriate questions about your preferred methods.
For Experienced Stylists
Test skills relevant to your clientele and service menu. If you specialise in colour, ask for a consultation and formula plan for a specific scenario. If you focus on cutting, request a particular style on a mannequin. Choose techniques that reflect actual work they’d perform in your salon.
Allow 30 to 45 minutes and provide scenarios that match your client demographic. You’re looking for confident execution, modern technique, and problem-solving when unexpected issues arise.
For Spa Therapists
Request an abbreviated version of your most popular treatment—perhaps 45 minutes of a signature massage or a partial facial sequence. Provide your actual products so you can see how they work with your specific range.
Watch pressure, rhythm, flow between techniques, and how they would customise the treatment based on client feedback. Great therapists adjust intuitively; average ones follow a rigid routine regardless of client response.
For Nail Technicians
Depending on your services, request either a gel application, nail art sample, or acrylic work. Observe preparation, product handling, sanitation practices, and finishing. Nail work requires precision—practical tests immediately reveal whether candidates possess it.
For Senior or Specialist Roles
For roles involving advanced colour correction, specialist treatments, or techniques that command premium pricing, design tests that match that complexity. Request consultations that demonstrate diagnostic ability, not just execution.
You might ask them to assess a challenging scenario and explain their approach before demonstrating the technique. This reveals both their knowledge depth and their ability to communicate technical concepts, which is essential for senior roles that often involve training junior staff.
The Legal and Ethical Framework
Practical tests must be fair, relevant, and legal. Here’s how to protect yourself and your candidates:
Always Disclose in Advance
Inform candidates during initial contact that your hiring process includes a practical assessment. Explain approximately how long it will take and what they should bring. Surprises create anxiety and don’t reflect how candidates perform in normal working conditions.
Keep Tests Reasonable in Length
A 15-45 minute practical test is reasonable. Asking candidates to work a full unpaid shift or complete multiple complex services crosses into unpaid labour. If you want to see them work for longer periods, that’s a paid trial shift, not an interview test.
Test the Same Skills for All Candidates
Use identical or equivalent tests for everyone applying for the same position. This ensures fair comparison and protects you from discrimination claims. If you test advanced colour for one candidate, test it for all.
Provide Necessary Tools and Products
Supply mannequins, models, or allow candidates to bring their own. Provide your products if you’re testing product-specific work. Don’t expect candidates to bring expensive supplies or models to your location.
Respect Their Time and Expertise
Professional courtesy matters. Acknowledge that you’re asking skilled professionals to demonstrate their craft. Thank them for their time. Provide feedback if they request it, even if they’re not successful.
Consider Compensation for Extended Tests
If your practical assessment exceeds one hour or requires candidates to provide services to actual clients, consider offering compensation. This shows respect for their expertise and time.
How to Score Practical Tests Objectively
Create a scoring rubric before you begin testing. This removes bias and allows fair comparison between candidates.
Use a Simple Point System
Rate each skill area from 0-5 points:
- 5 points: Exceeds expectations. Would confidently put them with your best clients immediately
- 4 points: Meets all expectations. Solid, competent work
- 3 points: Meets most expectations. Would need some refinement but shows potential
- 2 points: Below expectations. Significant gaps in technique
- 1 point: Minimal competency. Would require extensive retraining
- 0 points: Unable to perform the skill
Key Skill Areas to Score
For most beauty roles, score these categories:
- Technical execution and accuracy
- Work pace and efficiency
- Product knowledge and handling
- Sanitation and safety practices
- Client communication during service
- Attention to detail and finishing
- Professional presentation and conduct
- Response to feedback or questions
Set Your Minimum Standards
Decide your passing threshold before testing begins. For junior roles, you might accept candidates scoring 20+ out of 40 points, knowing you’ll provide training. For senior roles, you might require 32+ points because you need immediate competency.
Document scores immediately after each test whilst details are fresh. When you interview multiple candidates over several days, written scores prevent memory bias from affecting your decision.
Common Practical Test Mistakes to Avoid
Testing Irrelevant Skills
Don’t test advanced balayage if you mainly do basic colour. Don’t test hot stone massage if you don’t offer it. Test only skills candidates will actually use in your salon.
Making It Too Easy
A test that everyone passes perfectly doesn’t help you differentiate between candidates. Design assessments that reveal skill levels clearly, include at least one element that challenges even experienced professionals.
Making It Too Difficult
Conversely, don’t design tests that set candidates up to fail. If you specialise in extremely advanced techniques, test foundational skills first. You can always bring strong candidates back for additional assessment.
Focusing Only on Speed
Fast work matters, but accurate work matters more. A candidate who works slightly slower but produces flawless results often outperforms someone who rushes and makes mistakes requiring correction.
Ignoring Client Interaction
Technical skill without client connection creates a poor experience. Watch how candidates communicate, check for comfort, and build rapport whilst working. Both matter equally in a client-facing business.
Not Explaining Your Standards
If you have specific preferences, particular product application methods, certain consultation approaches, share this before testing. You’re assessing capability, not punishing candidates for not reading your mind.
Integrating Practical Tests Into Your Hiring Process
Position practical tests after initial interviews but before final offers. This sequence makes sense:
- Review applications and portfolios to shortlist qualified candidates
- Conduct initial interviews to assess culture fit and basic alignment
- Invite top candidates for practical testing
- Make hiring decisions based on combined interview and practical performance
This structure respects everyone’s time. You don’t test dozens of people, and candidates don’t invest in practical preparation unless they’re genuinely being considered.
When you’re ready to see candidates’ portfolio work before you even interview them, create your Salon Recruiter account to access visual profiles of qualified South African beauty professionals actively seeking positions.
What This Means for Your Next Hire
Practical testing transforms hiring from guesswork into evidence-based decisions. You’ll stop relying on impressive CVs and smooth interview answers. You’ll start seeing exactly what candidates can do before they touch your clients.
The time investment is minimal (usually 45 minutes per candidate). The protection is substantial and you’ll avoid hiring mistakes that cost thousands in lost productivity, client dissatisfaction, and recruitment do-overs.
Your reputation depends on consistent quality. Practical tests ensure that every person you hire can actually deliver that quality, not just talk about it.Ready to find candidates worth testing? Salon Recruiter connects you with pre-qualified beauty professionals across South Africa, complete with portfolios that showcase their actual work before you spend time on interviews.
